Crony capitalism as a management theory for 21st century India

function name : gab_postmeta_detail
11 Oct 2012

4 capitalism as a management theory for 21st century India&id=nc

Reams of paper have been spent writing management theories for companies in growth markets.

I remember how in one of my early lectures in management school, I asked the professor, “While we talk of core competence, how is it that groups like Tata, Reliance, Birlas diversify and continue to make money in places like India. According to the definition of core competence, they should not be in these markets.” The professor almost dismissed my question – and this was a question asked post 1991 reforms (the real ones).

Later on I read that in growth markets, core competence may not be a great strategy to work with as newer markets and opportunities open up. For example, in India when the telecom sector opened up, a bunch of our erstwhile conglomerates stepped in with their mobile phone service offerings. And a similar trend happened in the infrastructure sector. And when retail FDI happens, you will see a similar story there as well.

But then again, as the goings-on in the last couple of years have shown us, any company following any established management theory is sure to come a cropper in the face of the newest of all management theories. And it works. Especially in India. Especially with the UPA in power.

It can cock a snook at core competence. Monopolise and capture markets better than any marketing campaign. It can dance on the five forces model of Michael Porter. It can get exclusive licenses, first mover advantages, and deliver better results than Business Process Re-engineering. It is far more accurate than Lean Six Sigma. It is even more just-in-time than JIT. It can arrange finance at your doorstep when accounting standards tell you that you are not eligible for finance. It can win contracts when you are not even in the industry.

It is, in short, the baap of all management theories — one that management theorists and consultants has never quite managed to put on paper — The theory of crony capitalism.

In the words of Ogden Nash:

Heights by great men reached and kept,
were not attained by exertion,
but they while their companions slept,
were busy contacting the right person.

Indeed, the theory of crony capitalism works on a simple principle. The number of influential people who have your number on their phone is a good indicator. If they are movers and shakers in the Government who decide policies and float and award tenders, it means you can easily grow to stratospheric heights. If it is a minister who is deciding to give off coal blocks or spectrum on the cheap, you are in the league to become a billionaire. If you cannot fulfill this first step, then sorry – the crony capitalism theory may not work for you. You will have to make it on your own. Tough luck. Don’t forget to pay taxes, though.

Second: Have you heard of the word ethics? If your answer is yes, then please stand aside. If you think ethics is for everybody else, crony capitalism is for you.

Third: You need to pull strings. In the olden days of license distribution, some companies always got licenses no matter what. They set up all possible industries and made money. In these new days of liberalisation it is not that easy. You may have to find a foreign partner especially when all you do is own land and you know that a license to build a metro railway is up for grabs. But foreign partners are not too difficult to find — after all, India was a growth market, before it fell like a ton of BRICs (pun intended). Or you may be asked to submit a tender in 15 minutes – but this is the information age – it can be done. Sometimes, you have to create a need — like all you do is sell metal, while the tender is for building a hospital. That has to be arranged. This means that if the chap who floats the tender can add the golf course expertise as a pre-requisite to acquire land for a hospital, all you need to do is find a real estate firm which has built a golf course in its prospectus. It also helps to know lobbyists. These days lobbyists can be anybody – they are in disguise after the rather infamous expose of a lobbyist. A good disguise for them may be journalists. Ministers can also double up as loyalists – like, if a tourism minister vouches for your howitzers.

Fourth: You need to have a penchant for shells. Shell companies. Especially in Mauritius. Or Maldives. Or Cayman Islands. Some smart people have shell companies in India itself. You can even sell shell companies.

So, how do they make money? Oh simple. You get spectrum for cheap, you sell it at a fortune. You get coal blocks for cheap, you sell it for something. You get land on the cheap and then you get some ultra luxury penthouses in return. Return on investment, you see. Some kickback is involved, but usually it is lesser than the taxes you would pay if you are a normal income tax-paying geek.

Prerequisites: Some knowledge in creating trusts, NGO’s and a basic course in money laundering and tax planning. A penchant for throwing parties is appreciated. Attendance at big bashes is a must.

As you can see, many (shell) companies in India have made their fortunes this way.

Now, what if you are not an industrialist? You can still use crony capitalism. All you do is write bad things about BJP, Hindus or Gujarat 2002 (though this is fast approaching its sell by date) – and you will get funds. Another great option is to rant about persecution in Kashmir by the Indian authorities and somebody (related to a friendly neighbour’s spy agency) will sooner or later invite you for all-expenses-paid conferences and some free shopping. If you are lucky, the Government itself may put you on a plane and give you an all-expenses-paid holiday to Kashmir while you get to write a report that nobody reads. And if you are a leftist, that works too. Sooner or later, you will be invited for a corporate funded junket to spew leftist speeches on an unsuspecting audience.

As for me, I know this column just ended my chances…

Photo Courtesy:Selvin

Related links:


(c) NiTi Digital. Reproduction and/or reposting of this content is strictly prohibited under copyright laws.

4 capitalism as a management theory for 21st century India&id=nc

Please read our terms of use before posting comments.
  • manish

    YOU are so right.
    Crony Capitalism is a bane to any developing nation.
    not only does it kill enterprenuership in the market, it also kills the spirit of capitalism.
    what is required is not to earn profit by innovating and working hard, but to have the right connections.
    And, if we implicate congress for laying the foundation of this syatem in India, we are not only dead right, but are also tracing the root to this evil.
    To succeed in globalised world of today, what we require is not sycophant businessman, but a enterprenuer having the right set of

  • ANIL

    Niticentral should emerge as news paper also

  • ANIL

    solution ? illuminati ? i can be of some help…!!!

  • M Patel

    “Free Enterprise” and “Crony Capitalism” are antonyms. “Free Enterprise” is product of minimal and fair government regulation of economy. On the other hand, “Cronism” is the product of government playing favorites.
    Doling out “license/quota/permit” to favored corporation. This is a huge source of corruption in Socialist countries, like India, where government holds deadly discretionary power and red-tape is legendary.

    Neelakantan needs to clarify. Is he against “Free Enterprise” or “Cronism”? By natural Corollary, Opposing “Free Enterprise” means supporting some form of “Cronism” (i.e. Nehruvian-Socialist Cronism or Crony-Statism).

Recent Comments

Subscribe to Newsletter